Are souls judged on a sliding scale?

America was a strongly Christian country for much of its history. Sin was frowned upon. The Protestant moral collapse began when they embraced birth control. When a society’s morals are undermined, as ours are now, a vastly larger number of people believe that such things as birth control and fornication are not “sinful”.

In amoral societies, either fewer souls are saved, or God has some kind of a program that “adjusts” whatever level an individual’s faith and obedience have to be to merit salvation.

Consider John Smith, an agnostic who died today while riding his motorcycle without a helmet. His parents never took him to church, he never read the Bible, and the only thing he really knows about religion is what’s portrayed on The Simpson’s.

Naturally, he has spent his whole life in sin. But, God, in His infinite wisdom, knows that if John had lived in a more moral society, and had a more religious background, that he would not have been living in sin with his girlfriend. God knows that if John hadn’t been told a million times that “it isn’t really a baby”, he would not have encouraged her to have an abortion. God also knows that if John had been taught that it was wrong to steal, he wouldn’t have been taking a few dollars now and then from his employer.

God knows that John’s soul was lost when his parents made the decision to raise him “to find himself”.

II.

Fred’s on the other side of the coin. He’s been raised in The Church. He knows his Catechism. He’s read and re-read the Bible. He knows the Commandments. He goes to Church every week. But, he died a few minutes ago after he fell, knocked himself unconscious, and then tumbled down a hotel elevator shaft while having an affair with a woman he’d met on-line. His death was so fast he didn’t have time to ask for forgiveness.

III.

Their two souls arrive at the Pearly Gates at the same time. Will either be admitted?

Author's Notes:

Related:

Why did God give “Food Tests” to every…

Catholics are the only people on earth blessed to pass "God's Final Food Test" by receiving His Body...

Catholics see: Our Future is more important than…

Catholics understand: In God, Time and Space are One. ~ Question 1: “How does Today’s Reading from Hebrews...

The Forgotten Words of Jesus That Expose Protestant…

For over 2,000 years, countless Protestant groups have refused to obey the direct and unambiguous words Jesus used...

Catholics know what Jesus teaches: There are…

Catholics correctly conclude: "Demons know more than the 'poor captives' whom they lead to disobey The Church-Creating Word...

Today, we see what causes “Confusion…

It is a blessing to "Be Catholic" and not among the flocks of "vultures" that "gather" in every...
Ceiling painting of Christ and his apostles

Not yet used, 5/29/2025 – 2

Today’s Reading shows how St. Paul gives us another example of Standing Firmly for Jesus and His Church...